Poll
Question: Move 
Option 1: 24/23, 13/9
votes: 4
Option 2: 13/9, 6/5
votes: 0
Option 3: 13/8
votes: 0
Option 4: 24/20, 6/5
votes: 0
Option 5: 24/23, 24/20
votes: 1
Title: Game 2, move 1:Herd 4-1
Post by: diane on April 06, 2012, 11:42:41 PM
Post by: diane on April 06, 2012, 11:42:41 PM
Gnu tormented steifnu by refusing to give any racing rolls..so he ended up gammoned by a whisker...
File attached..Herd at 4-0.
Lets see how the crawford treats him.
File attached..Herd at 4-0.
Lets see how the crawford treats him.
Title: Re: Game 2, move 1:Herd 4-1
Post by: ah_clem on April 07, 2012, 04:26:36 AM
Post by: ah_clem on April 07, 2012, 04:26:36 AM
match stats through game 1
Basically a pretty clean game on both sides. The Herd messed up two checker plays - I'll roll them out and append the rollout to the moves in question.
The two-ply analysis dings steifnu for taking the cube (reflected in the stats below), but the rollout says it was a fairly massive take, so the one cube error that prompts the "Awful!" cube play rating is actually not an error at all. Looks like both sides had immaculate cube play. This one is worth a second look since gnu 2-ply analysis gets it wrong. Kudos to steifnu for outplaying the bot!
I'll roll out the disputed moves and post a revised stats summary in a few days. But the story so far is that the herd played textbook short match tactics - play aggressively to get some gammon chances and then turn the cube. steifnu ran into some bad dice, but that just just goes to show why the aggressive play makes sense - when the dice go your way, hit your opponent and make sure that he doesn't get up. (c:
Stiefnu Herd
Chequer Play Statistics:
Total moves 24 24
Unforced moves 17 21
Unmarked moves 24 22
Moves marked doubtful 0 1
Moves marked bad 0 1
Moves marked very bad 0 0
Error total EMG (MWC) -0.018 ( -0.261%) -0.208 ( -1.854%)
Error rate mEMG (MWC) -1.1 ( -0.015%) -9.9 ( -0.088%)
Chequerplay rating Supernatural Advanced
Luck Statistics:
Rolls marked very lucky 0 0
Rolls marked lucky 1 0
Rolls unmarked 17 23
Rolls marked unlucky 5 1
Rolls marked very unlucky 1 0
Luck total EMG (MWC) -2.736 (-33.508%) -0.324 ( -5.193%)
Luck rate mEMG (MWC) -114.0 ( -1.396%) -13.5 ( -0.216%)
Luck rating Go to bed None
Cube Statistics:
Total cube decisions 24 7
Close or actual cube decisions 1 3
Doubles 0 1
Takes 1 0
Passes 0 0
Missed doubles below CP (EMG (MWC)) 0 0
Missed doubles above CP (EMG (MWC)) 0 0
Wrong doubles below DP (EMG (MWC)) 0 0
Wrong doubles above TG (EMG (MWC)) 0 0
Wrong takes (EMG (MWC)) 1 (-0.345 ( -2.519%)) 0
Wrong passes (EMG (MWC)) 0 0
Error total EMG (MWC) -0.345 ( -2.519%) +0.000 ( +0.000%)
Error rate mEMG (MWC) -345.1 ( -2.519%) +0.0 ( +0.000%)
Cube decision rating Awful! Supernatural
Overall Statistics:
Error total EMG (MWC) -0.363 ( -2.780%) -0.208 ( -1.854%)
Error rate mEMG (MWC) -20.2 ( -0.154%) -8.7 ( -0.077%)
Snowie error rate -7.6 ( +0.000%) -4.3 ( +0.000%)
Overall rating Casual player Advanced
Actual result -34.30% +34.30%
Luck adjusted result -5.99% +5.99%
Luck based FIBS rating diff. -93.45
Error based abs. FIBS rating 1773.3 1912.0
Chequerplay errors rating loss 14.7 138.0
Cube errors rating loss 262.0 0.0
Basically a pretty clean game on both sides. The Herd messed up two checker plays - I'll roll them out and append the rollout to the moves in question.
The two-ply analysis dings steifnu for taking the cube (reflected in the stats below), but the rollout says it was a fairly massive take, so the one cube error that prompts the "Awful!" cube play rating is actually not an error at all. Looks like both sides had immaculate cube play. This one is worth a second look since gnu 2-ply analysis gets it wrong. Kudos to steifnu for outplaying the bot!
I'll roll out the disputed moves and post a revised stats summary in a few days. But the story so far is that the herd played textbook short match tactics - play aggressively to get some gammon chances and then turn the cube. steifnu ran into some bad dice, but that just just goes to show why the aggressive play makes sense - when the dice go your way, hit your opponent and make sure that he doesn't get up. (c:
Stiefnu Herd
Chequer Play Statistics:
Total moves 24 24
Unforced moves 17 21
Unmarked moves 24 22
Moves marked doubtful 0 1
Moves marked bad 0 1
Moves marked very bad 0 0
Error total EMG (MWC) -0.018 ( -0.261%) -0.208 ( -1.854%)
Error rate mEMG (MWC) -1.1 ( -0.015%) -9.9 ( -0.088%)
Chequerplay rating Supernatural Advanced
Luck Statistics:
Rolls marked very lucky 0 0
Rolls marked lucky 1 0
Rolls unmarked 17 23
Rolls marked unlucky 5 1
Rolls marked very unlucky 1 0
Luck total EMG (MWC) -2.736 (-33.508%) -0.324 ( -5.193%)
Luck rate mEMG (MWC) -114.0 ( -1.396%) -13.5 ( -0.216%)
Luck rating Go to bed None
Cube Statistics:
Total cube decisions 24 7
Close or actual cube decisions 1 3
Doubles 0 1
Takes 1 0
Passes 0 0
Missed doubles below CP (EMG (MWC)) 0 0
Missed doubles above CP (EMG (MWC)) 0 0
Wrong doubles below DP (EMG (MWC)) 0 0
Wrong doubles above TG (EMG (MWC)) 0 0
Wrong takes (EMG (MWC)) 1 (-0.345 ( -2.519%)) 0
Wrong passes (EMG (MWC)) 0 0
Error total EMG (MWC) -0.345 ( -2.519%) +0.000 ( +0.000%)
Error rate mEMG (MWC) -345.1 ( -2.519%) +0.0 ( +0.000%)
Cube decision rating Awful! Supernatural
Overall Statistics:
Error total EMG (MWC) -0.363 ( -2.780%) -0.208 ( -1.854%)
Error rate mEMG (MWC) -20.2 ( -0.154%) -8.7 ( -0.077%)
Snowie error rate -7.6 ( +0.000%) -4.3 ( +0.000%)
Overall rating Casual player Advanced
Actual result -34.30% +34.30%
Luck adjusted result -5.99% +5.99%
Luck based FIBS rating diff. -93.45
Error based abs. FIBS rating 1773.3 1912.0
Chequerplay errors rating loss 14.7 138.0
Cube errors rating loss 262.0 0.0